Angel Island Immigration Station: Ellis Island of the West


Americans were worried. The economy had weakened. There were concerns about the rising cost of food, and many people were out of work. The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 was proposed as a way to solve these problems, a panacea for unemployment. Proponents of the law argued that the influx of Chinese laborers had left no jobs for Anglo-Americans. It was time to put a stop to these immigrants, they argued. A San Francisco Chronicle article in 1873 read, "The Chinese Invasion! They Are Coming, 900,000 Strong.” The Chinese Exclusion Act was widely supported and passed easily to become law. But even at the time, people spoke out against it as “wickedness and injustice” towards the Chinese people who had worked to build infrastructure across the western United States and beyond.
Chinese workers building the Central Pacific Railroad, California, Photo by Alfred A. Hart, 1867

Chinese workers building the Central Pacific Railroad, California, Photo by Alfred A. Hart, 1867


Image

Angel Island Immigration Station, Dormitory B



The Chinese Exclusion Act was one of the first in a series of laws in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries that made an effort to stop or slow down immigration of groups who were seen as ethnically or racially inferior. 

But the United States is a nation of immigrants from across the globe. While many people immigrated through the better-known Ellis Island in New York, there was not a similar immigration processing station to manage immigrants coming from Asian countries via the West Coast. Angel Island off the coast of San Francisco, California opened as an immigrant detention center in 1910. It processed hundreds of thousands of immigrants mostly from China, Japan, Russia, and South Asia for over three decades until its closure in 1940. Angel Island, which was originally home to the Huimen tribe of the Coast Miwok, was chosen for its isolation, making it easier to control potential outbreaks of disease.


Unfortunately, conditions at the detention facility were often poor. Also, unlike Ellis Island which had a quick processing system and low rejection rate of between one and three percent and 98% being admitted within a few hours or days, Angel Island was explicitly created to keep out the people arriving there and had a rejection rate of around 18%. Immigrants arriving at Angel Island had to endure lengthy detention periods, lasting weeks or months with the longest recorded stay of 22 months. While all immigrants went through a general physical examination, Chinese immigrants dealt with extensive interrogations to ensure that they were not “paper sons” or daughters.
Seen as expensive and inefficient, Angel Island Immigration Station was closed in 1940 with the operations moving to the mainland, but the Chinese Exclusion Act wasn’t repealed until 1943. Today, the site can be visited and toured with some areas restored.

Image

Immigration interview on Angel Island, 1923. Photo courtesy of Records of the Public Health Service (Group 90), National Archives.

Image

Poem 135 from Island carved on the walls of a lavatory room on the first floor of the detention barracks at the Angel Island Immigration Station, author unknown. Photo by Ying Diao


During these long periods of detention, some immigrants took to writing on the walls of their cells or barracks. Many of these poems have been preserved and documented and express themes of hope, anger, and despair. Poem 61 was carved by an anonymous detainee into the walls of the Detention Barracks at Angel Island and reads: 

Bored and filled with a hundred feelings, I am imprisoned in the building. 

Seeing the surroundings stirs one who is sad. How can one stop the tears? 

I recall the ship starting off for the land of America.

Looking back, the moon has repeated a cycle.


Looking for picture books featuring Chinese Americans during this time? 

I am an American : the Wong Kim Ark story by Martha Brockenbrough with Grace Lin ; illustrated by Julia Kuo, nonfiction 

Paper son : the inspiring story of Tyrus Wong, immigrant and artist by Julie Leung ; illustrated by Chris Sasaki, nonfiction

Landed by Milly Lee; illustrated by Yangsook Choi, fiction

Li on Angel Island (Smithsonian Historical Fiction) by Veeda Bybee, fiction

Mountain chef : how one man lost his groceries, changed his plans, and helped cook up the National Park Service by Annette Bay Pimentel ; illustrated by Rich Lo, nonfiction